The Mutual Way

For almost 160 years, Ontario mutual insurance companies have been – and still are – about people coming together to protect themselves in a common need. Because there are no stockholders in a mutual insurance company, the interests of the policyholders are served first.

Small, but mighty.

Ontario Mutuals are more than 40 independent insurance companies that grew in the small towns and rural areas that form the backbone of our province. But don’t let our small size fool you. Together, we represent one of the strongest, most secure financial networks in the world.

Rooted in your community, we’ve sheltered generations.

The spirit of mutual insurance is woven into the fabric of every community. It’s the spirit of coming together for the greater good. While many of our member companies began as farm mutuals in the mid 1800s, today we offer a full range of home, auto, commercial and farm insurance tailored to protect you and your family.

Premiums stay where they do the most good — in your community.

With Mutuals, premiums stay in the community, employing neighbours, supporting the local economy and giving back. We invest in local projects and support what matters most to our policyholders. We’ve been buying local for generations, and community spirit has been part of our style for nearly 160 years.

You’re more than a policyholder, you have a voice. Let it be heard.

When you buy a policy, you automatically become a member of that company. That means you have a voice in important issues like electing a board of directors at the annual meeting.

We’re people-centred, not call-centred.

You will always be treated like a person, not a number. Whenever you have a question or a claim, someone you know and trust will be right there to help. It’s not the way every insurance company does business, but it’s the Mutual Way.

Discover the Cayuga Mutual difference today.

Are You Ready for Spring?

February 13, 2018 | Did You Know |
Read More

Sayers Home Hardware: End of an Era

March 26, 2018 | In Your Community |
Read More

Staff Supporting Juravinski Cancer Centre

September 14, 2017 | In Your Community | Read More

Address & Business Hours

23 King Street West
Cayuga, ON N0A 1E0
Monday to Friday
8:30 AM to 4:30 PM
Excluding Statutory Holidays

Holiday Hours
Monday, September 3, 2018 CLOSED

Telephone Numbers

Local: (905) 772-5498
Toll Free: (800) 567-3381
Fax: (905) 772-3921

Claims (During Business Hours)
Local: (905) 772-5498
Toll Free: (800) 567-3381

Claims (Outside of Business Hours)
Toll Free: (866) 410-1226