Nominations are in for the Readers’ Choice Awards in the Sachem. It is our great honour to be nominated in several categories:

  • Best Insurance Company
  • Best Agent – Phil Wellings
  • Best Agent – Mike Cowan

On behalf of Cayuga Mutual’s staff, agents, management and directors, Thank You for your nominations.  You help us realize our mission – ‘To provide peace of mind to our community through financial stability, quality insurance products and services.’

Please watch for the voting to begin online 24 hours a day from September 8th to 25th. Just go to and click on the Readers’ Choice button to make your vote count.

Thank you again for the nominations.

Discover the Cayuga Mutual difference today.