Cart - Cayuga Mutual Insurance

X

Important Changes are Coming to Auto Insurance. CLICK HERE to find out how if affects you!

Skip to content

AGENTS
QUOTE
CONTACT
- Contact My Agent
CLAIM
PAYMENT
- Make a Payment
WORDINGS
BLOG
CAREERS
CLIENT PORTAL

CONTACT US TODAY: 1-800-567-3381

Search for:

THE MUTUAL WAY
HOME
AUTO
FARM
COMMERCIAL

Search for:

Cartdtadmin2021-08-05T14:26:33-04:30

Your cart is currently empty.

Return to shop

ADDRESS & HOURS

23 King Street
Cayuga, ON N0A 1E0
Contact Us

TO SEE OUR SPECIAL HOLIDAY HOURS VISIT OUR CONTACT PAGE

REGULAR HOURS
Mon-Thur: 8:30 AM to 4:30 PM
Friday: 8:30 AM to 3:00 PM
Sat-Sun: Closed
Excluding Statutory
Holidays

TELEPHONE NUMBERS

Local: (905) 772-5498
Toll Free: (800) 567-3381
Fax: (905) 772-3921

Claims
(During Business Hours)
Local: (905) 772-5498
Toll Free: (800) 567-3381

Claims
(Outside of Business Hours)
Toll Free: (877) 488-6642

LEARN MORE

About Us
Career Opportunities
The Mutual Way
Vision, Mission & Core Values
Financials
Privacy Policy
Accessibility Policy
Conflict of Interest Policy
Complaint Resolution
Our Service Territory

USEFUL LINKS

Director Access
Ontario Mutual Insurance Association
Farm Mutual Re
Insurance Bureau of Canada
Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario

OUR BLOG

Why Home-Based Businesses Need Insurance?
September 29, 2026
Protect Your Home Office. READ MORE
What Insurance Do I Need for a Boat? | Boat Insurance Guide in Ontario | Cayuga Mutual
July 31, 2026
Boat Insurance in Ontario: READ MORE

View more blog posts

Message to: Michelle Hamilton

140 characters remaining.

Message to: Charlene Croft

140 characters remaining.

Message to: Rebecca Flatt

140 characters remaining.

Message to: Jaden Brownell

140 characters remaining.

Message to: Emily Russell

140 characters remaining.

Message to: Trent Byleveld

140 characters remaining.

Message to: Starr Doleman

140 characters remaining.

Message to: Mittu Sharma

140 characters remaining.

Message to: Bo Chausse

140 characters remaining.

Message to: Phil Wellings

140 characters remaining.

Message to: Jake Smith

140 characters remaining.

Message to: Krista Neill

140 characters remaining.

Message to: Doug Murphy

140 characters remaining.

Message to: Dale Killins

140 characters remaining.

Message to: Barb Currie

140 characters remaining.

Message to: Mike Cowan

140 characters remaining.

Message to: Ken Benito

140 characters remaining.

Message to: Randy Bacher

140 characters remaining.