WE THINK LOCAL IS BETTER
AND HERE’S WHY

Home Mutual Insurance

HOME

Your home protected. Home insurance for your peace of mind.

LEARN MORE

AUTO

Your auto protected. Personal service is what drives us.

LEARN MORE
Farm Mutual Insurance

FARM

Your farm protected. Protecting farmers for more than 140 years.

LEARN MORE
Commercial Mutual Insurance

COMMERCIAL

Your business protected.  Providing 100% local service, just like you.

LEARN MORE

DISCOVER THE CAYUGA MUTUAL DIFFERENCE TODAY

REQUEST A QUOTE

SAFE WINTER DRIVING
5 THINGS YOU NEED TO DO.

LEARN MORE
Cayuga Mutual Insurance

TESTIMONIALS FROM
OUR CLIENTS

“I just want to let you know how pleased I am about the car repair after my recent accident. Cayuga Mutual and Fix Auto made the process easy and stress free.  Thanks for the excellent service!”

S.D.

“Cayuga Mutual is full of such nice people and they did a great job saving me money. They understand rural needs very well and deliver high-quality service.”

L.O.

“This company has so many wonderful employees that go out of their way to help me as quickly as possible. The price was right and the policy covers my farm property. Thank you Cayuga Mutual. I am very pleased to be your customer.”

LAURIE O.

“Cayuga Mutual has been my insurance agent for years. I’ve worked with multiple agents over the years and I have always received great personalized service. Always honest with you, this insurance company won’t give you the run around like others.”

MARK C.
“I just want to let you know how pleased I am about the car repair after my recent accident. Cayuga Mutual and Fix Auto made the process easy and stress free. Thanks for the excellent service!”
SANDY DOYLE
“I am new to Cayuga Mutual and I have been working with Jake Smith and he is amazing. Always answers all my questions and goes above and beyond to ensure I am getting the best rates possible. Would highly recommend Jake to everyone.”
NICOLE KANE
“The staff are attentive to your needs.”
ADRIAN BARRIOS
“The best insurance company you will ever go to! Randy Bacher is your go to guy!”
RICHARD J. COLLINS