Home

Cayuga Mutual - Insurance Company

  • Peace of Mind Since 1875

    At Cayuga Mutual Insurance we understand the nature of the Mutual Way is based on Mutual respect. We try hard to provide products and services that will "work for you."

    Please feel free to contact our team of professionals to learn more about our company and how we might fit your needs.

    What is a Mutual?

    Mutual Insurance is knowing that someone is there for you when you need them the most ... someone you can speak to .... someone you can meet with ... someone you know. 

    As a proud member of the Ontario Mutual Insurance Association; Cayuga Mutual Insurance has never lost sight of its basic principle of neighbour helping neighbour ... we invite you to experience the difference.
  • 2009 Annual Statement

    The 2009 Annual Statement is now available for download here.

    Any policyholder may request a paper copy of the annual statement by contacting the office during normal business hours at (905) 772-5498.

    Bursary Applications Available



    Cayuga Mutual Insurance provides an annual bursary to children of our policyholders. Pictured here is Chairman Bob Young presenting the $500 cheque to Greg Deleemans, our 2009 recipient.

    Applications are available for download here and must be submitted by July 1, 2010.