Home

Cayuga Mutual - Insurance Company

  • Find Us

    Claims

    If you have an enquiry regarding a claim please contact the Claims Department Tel: 905-772-5498

    Send an Email

    Website Inquiry

    If you wish to submit an enquiry via our website please fill in our Enquiry Form.

    Agents

    If you would like your local Agent to visit you, you can find their contact details in the Our People section.

    Directions.

    From Hamilton:  Follow Highway 6 South to Caledonia, turn left onto Caithness Street (Highway 54) and follow to Cayuga. Turn right onto Talbot Street (Highway 3), right onto Cayuga Street, then left onto King Street.

    Cayuga Mutuals Ins. Co. 23 King Street Cayuga, Ontario N0A1E0

    Tel: 905-772-5498

    Fax: 905-772-3921

    Email: info@cayugamutual.com